Mushroom Barley Soup

Mushroom Barley Soup

As I mentioned in my Autumn Delivery post, I make a mean mushroom barley soup. It’s such a warming treat on a cold autumn day, and is one of Marc’s favorite things. I should make it more often, since this soup is just so satisfying. There are a few key techniques and ingredients that are crucial and set it apart from other recipes.

One, is that the small brown cremini mushrooms (they are baby portabellos) are more flavorful than buttons, and need to be seared before being added to the soup. Searing them really brings out the intense mushroom flavor and gives them a little meaty texture. Secondly, deglazing the mushrooms with white wine brings some acid to the party and also brightens up the mushrooms. Thirdly, and perhaps most important, the stock. The absolute best pre-made mushroom broth/stock/bullion we’ve found is Pacific Organic Mushroom Broth. We use it for mushroom risotto too.

Pacific’s mushroom broth has a rich mushroom flavor and isn’t overly seasoned. Some broths/stocks can be way too salty. This one isn’t. Anyway, you are welcome to make your own mushroom broth from scratch, but if you don’t want to spend the time, Pacific mushroom broth is incredibly flavorful. This recipe is from the Fields of Greens cookbook and I’ve altered it a bit. As usual, please use as many organic/local/sustainable ingredients as you can.

Soup Ingredients

Mushroom Barley Soup
6 ½ cups of Mushroom stock (Pacific Organic Mushroom stock is great)
1 tbsp unsalted butter
1 onion, diced
salt and pepper to taste
6 garlic cloves, finely chopped
½ cup dry white wine
1 small carrot, diced
1 large celery, diced
1 med. potato, diced
1/3 cup pearl barley (not quick cooking)
1 bay leaf
1 to 1½ lbs brown cremini mushrooms, diced
olive oil for sauteeing
1tbsp chopped fresh herbs: parsley, marjoram, thyme and sage (sage is my favorite, but you use what you have)

Heat butter in soup pot and add onion, a little salt and pepper. Sautee over medium heat until they just start to soften a little.
Add carrot and celery and sautee a couple more minutes to begin caramelization.
Add bay leaf, barley, potato and mushroom broth. Bring to a boil, cover and cook on medium heat for 30-40 minutes, until barley is tender.
While vegetables and barley cook, sear mushrooms in 2 separate batches in a skillet over high heat, using olive oil, dash of salt, and a few pinches pepper. Don’t stir. I know you’ll want to, but leave them be. Cook over high heat until golden, and reduced in size by about 1/2, stir once and continue to sear 1-2 minutes.
Add half of the garlic and stir again.
Add half of the white wine and stir to get all the nice bits dislodged from the pan (deglaze). Add first pan full of mushrooms to soup pot and repeat with second batch of mushrooms. Add the fresh herbs at the end. Season with salt and pepper to taste.

13 thoughts on “Mushroom Barley Soup”

  1. Bri, this sounds so wonderful. We have a very cold day today in Mel, and I would love to taste your delicious dish.

  2. Anh – Yes, wonderful on a spring day down unda’ too! Thanks for stopping by.

    Manggy – Man, typhoon, huh? Sounds scary to me. All we have here are raging wildfires and earthquakes. Keep warm!

  3. Bee – Great! Let me know if you make it.

    Erin – Thanks! Barley is such good homey food, and this recipe uses so little, you can ease into it…in case there are skeptical eaters.

    Puspha – Thanks!

    JEP – Wonderful! Let me know if you make it.

  4. Great recipe! The directions do not indicate when to put in the potato so I forgot to put it in. I made it last night–sans potato and still very tasty.

  5. Jennifer – Thanks so much for commenting, and bringing my error to light. The original recipe doesn’t call for potatoes, so I missed that. I’m so glad you made it, and enjoyed it.

  6. very good soup–i doubled the carrot, doubled the barley, and doubled the celery, and added a bit of cream and butter for good measure. VERY YUMMY!!!! also, i used “better than boullion” mushroom base instead of the pacific mushroom broth.

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *